Neither one will work properly... Just scale them down to 57x57 or 72x72 for the HD and look at the result. Detail like the thin outlines, the little bunnies fading away, the ocean wave, etc. will be lost in the small version. Think about the tiny sizes when you design the icon. The yellow outline is about as thin as you can go. My suggestion would be to either reduce it to just the bunny head or just the text with a simple backdrop behind it (the fence is already on the border of being too complex). Good luck!
Comments
Thanks!