Icon Opinions

tenrdrmer

Ok so im going to be sending an update in to fix a bug on my game as soon as itunes reopens and I figured why not redo the icon since I have never been happy with it and others have mentioned to me that its not the best.
so heres the itunes link to where you can see the current icon
http://itunes.apple.com/us/app/galactic-towers/id408887764?mt=8

Heres that same image without the shiny icon
http://www.appsoluteentertainment.com/uploads/5/1/1/6/5116615/7031849.png

And heres what im considering replacing with. http://www.appsoluteentertainment.com/uploads/5/1/1/6/5116615/9005751.png

Let me know what you think and honestly please just tell me if you don't like any of them

Thanks
Aaron

frario

Sorry to be frank: it is not appealing. In the icon you could try to keep a unity in style (cartoon vs photo). I'll try to send you a sketch.

tenrdrmer

The fire is not a photo. Does it still look real?

frario

I made 4 fast sketches (from zero). You are free of using every graphic in it.






Merry christmas!

frario

Yes it does. I can send you the illustartor file if you are not satisfied with it.

frario

Last one:

tenrdrmer

Well I Mean if your offer up free art. tenrdrmer(At)yahoo
We can talk more there.

diegocs

frario this look sick man, the last one frario posted for sure , you should consider it tenrdrmer

tenrdrmer

Yeah no doubt they are awesome. waiting on an email to talk more about these.

frario

my email is info[a t]frario-dot-it
write me fast cause I'm in a rush!

Edit: don't worry, I'm forgetting sometime that I've an iphone

@diegocs thanks

OldAccountPlzIgnore

Wow they look awesome frario if you don't mind me asking what program did you use to make them?

MotherHoose

Last one of frario. jump out in store and on device.

ah @frario ... great job!

MH

tenrdrmer

My personal Preference is the last one in the set of 4 I like how theres two blocks.
Anyone think its an issue the blocks are different from the actual block in the game?

@Eightbit.
He mentioned an illustrator file so I would assume adobe illustrator

scitunes

tenrdrmer said:

Anyone think its an issue the blocks are different from the actual block in the game?

Not at all.

diegocs

I think the icon should look more appealin than the game itself, it is what makes a game eyecatching