Stylized or Detailed art?

Riffel

What art style AppStore Consumer likes?

Stylized


Detailed


More about this game development here:
http://gamesalad.com/forums/topic.php?id=10569

jonmulcahy

I like both

JackBQuick

I like the brighter colours for Detailed better but not what looks like blood on the bone. I'm afraid, though, that I don't recognize what I'm looking at.

quantumsheep

JackBQuick said:
I like the brighter colours for Detailed better but not what looks like blood on the bone. I'm afraid, though, that I don't recognize what I'm looking at.

A severed leg, I think. The yellow bits are claws, maybe?

Or is it a Zombie finger???

I like both versions! Not a lot of help I know! Maybe the 'detailed' one has the edge?

QS

JackBQuick

quantumsheep said:
Or is it a Zombie finger???

Yes! I see it now! And the yellow part is the nail. Okay, the blood isn't too bad -- somehow, being zombie blood makes it better

beefy_clyro

detailed

iPhoneDevForMe

You could use the detailed art for cut scenes and stylized for the actual gameplay.

Maybe even have the gameplay be a balanced mixture of both!

In the end, if you were to choose ONLY ONE, then detailed it is!

Taidaken

depends on the game i think.. tho both versions are cool

Valan

I like the more stylized version. It looks more cartoony.

ChipmunkGames

STYLIZED! I hate detailed icons. Remember, they are VERY small on the iphone screen.

Riffel

yes, this is an amputee finger :-)
this is not an app icon.
Detailed is double working time...

Thank you for comments and vote!

butterbean

I personally like the stylized one, looks more "cartoony" and appealing to me than the detailed one

ktfright

butterbean said:
I personally like the stylized one, looks more "cartoony" and appealing to me than the detailed one

+1

Riffel

we have a tie :-)